Shipowner Did Not Obtain Summary Judgment Where Affidavits Only Contained Statements That Were Conclusory
ROGER PERALTA VERSUS AMERICAN CONTINENTAL LINE, LLC, et al
CIVIL ACTION NO. 03-2497 SECTION "N" (1)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
2004 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 8103
May 6, 2004, Decided
May 6, 2004, Filed; May 7, 2004, Entered
PROCEDURAL POSTURE: Plaintiff seaman brought suit against defendant tugboat owner and alleged barge owner, seeking recovery for personal injury, alleging claims of negligence under the Jones Act and unseaworthiness under general maritime law. The tugboat owner moved for summary judgment, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56.
OVERVIEW: The seaman fell on a barge attached to the tugboat and was injured. The seaman brought a negligence action against the tugboat owner, and in its motion for summary judgment, the tugboat owner claimed that the seaman was solely responsible for his fall and resulting injuries. However, the court found that the tugboat owner failed to defeat the negligence claim by only making conclusory statements regarding its purported lack of a duty. While the tugboat owner alleged that it did not have a duty to warn of open and obvious conditions, the tugboat owner failed to prove its absence of a duty. Thus, there was a genuine material fact as to whether the tugboat owner exercised reasonable care under the circumstances surrounding the seaman's injury. Next, the seaman challenged the seaworthiness of the barge, and the tugboat owner sought summary judgment on the ground that it did not own or possess an interest in the barge. Regardless, the tugboat owner failed to offer any evidence, by way of affidavit, contract with the alleged barge owner or any other material, to support its assertion. Therefore, the tugboat owner was not granted summary judgment as to liability of unseaworthiness.
OUTCOME: The tugboat owner's motion for summary judgment was granted insofar as it sought dismissal of any claim for unseaworthiness of the tugboat. The motion was denied in all other respects.
