Damages Affirmed In Action For Violation Of The Duty To Rescue Along With A Reduction Of 70% Based On Comparitive Fault
STEPHEN C. SMITH VERSUS TIDEWATER INC.
NO. 2004-CA-0195
COURT OF APPEAL OF LOUISIANA, FOURTH CIRCUIT
04-0195 (La.App. 4 Cir. 3/02/05);
2005 La. App. LEXIS 905
March 2, 2005, Judgment Released
PROCEDURAL POSTURE: Defendant employer, a marine company, appealed a decision of the Civil District Court, Orleans Parish (Louisiana), which awarded damages to plaintiff employee in finding that the defendant violated the duty to rescue plaintiff after he fell overboard. Plaintiff was also awarded damages for wrongful termination.
OVERVIEW: Plaintiff was working for defendant when he allegedly fell overboard off the coast of Puerto Rico. Plaintiff swam for nearly 20 hours to shore. The court held that defendant complied with 46 C.F.R. § 26.03-2(b). However, once the Coast Guard began searching for plaintiff, defendant brought its tow into port claiming that it created a burden in the search efforts. The court held that even if that were so, defendant's action of spending over three hours in port while its seaman was lost at sea was not diligent. Further, while 46 C.F.R. § 4.06 required chemical testing on those directly involved, the testing could have been done later. But for the vessel returning the barge to port so that it could remain on schedule, plaintiff may have been rescued and his post-traumatic stress disorder lessened. However, the trial court erred in not assessing plaintiff a percentage of contributory negligence. Therefore, because defendant was not negligent in plaintiff's actual fall, it assigned plaintiff 70 percent fault. Finally, the court held that the retaliatory discharge award was proper because there was evidence that plaintiff was fired in because he was considering filing a claim.
OUTCOME: The court amended the judgment to cast plaintiff 70 percent comparatively at fault. The award for retaliatory discharge was amended to reflect the intention to include an award for lost wages and loss of future income.
